|
Post by sorenyamashita on Apr 17, 2015 11:11:08 GMT
OKAY, so today I was thinking about the identity of the girl who is staying with Sera...now here is my theory...I propose that Elena Miyano is the mystery child!
AHow? Through the silver bullet project, belive it or not this prototype of APTX could have been even more dangerous and perhaps Elena escaped after Pisco tried to kill her with her own drug becoming a shrunken child simmilar to her daughter
...the statement I just made is VERY possible becuase as the readers of the Detective Conan we know pisco told Shiho that her parents died in and "accident..." we can assume that at the time Elena died Shiho was maybe 4-5 years old...assuming the Silver Bullet had a stronger abbilty to make victims younger or kill them, as APTX does...it's possible that Elena De-aged to that of a baby under a year old...but all possible jokes aside...this mystery child is a conundrum of itself as Gosho gives his fans very to go off...but there is one shocking piece of evidence...when the girl says
"I'm your sister from the outside". What does that mean? it's highly possible that she means from outside common knowledge...after all the organization is not considered common knowledge.
assuming Akai and Sera's family found the child it would make sense , this girl would be considered a sister and the timing would be perfect 10 to 13 years before the actual story plenty of time for Akai to Join the FBI and for Shiho to grow up...
But hey that's just a theory, an Anime Theory!
|
|
|
Post by Nikudou Natsumi on Apr 17, 2015 13:06:32 GMT
That's an interesting idea . . . But if it was Elena Miyano, and Akai and Sera's family adopted her, how would you explain the family resemblance?
|
|
|
Post by Soren on Apr 17, 2015 19:00:41 GMT
Well families do have unique traits,but Elena was foreign so it's possible that she would have a simmolar eye shape due to the fact that fans have never seen her eyes.
|
|
|
Post by Nikudou Natsumi on Apr 17, 2015 19:59:23 GMT
True . . . hm . . .
What does anyone else think?
|
|
|
Post by Mikauzoran on Apr 18, 2015 0:16:01 GMT
Well, I too have considered that maybe Elena could be the mystery child, but I'm far more convinced that it's Sera's mom or aunt or something, the main reason being because of the family resemblance.
I find fault in your reasoning about the eyes. A crappy writer would do something like you've described, and Sensei is not a crappy mystery writer despite his failings in the world of angst and romance. When you have a distinctive feature like that in a mystery series, it's not a throwaway thing. It's an important clue. It's not impossible that it's a red herring, but I would be disappointed in Sensei if that were the case.
I could accept that the mystery child was Elena Miyano if she were also a relative of the Sera/Akai clan to account for the resemblance, but then I would be disappointed because Akai and Akemi would then be cousins or something. So yeah. It's a good, viable theory, but I don't think it's right.
|
|
|
Post by StarlightDragons on Apr 18, 2015 3:49:46 GMT
Personally, I'd prefer if it was Sera's mom - Elena coming back to life gives me the same "yeah, no" feeling that bringing Toichi back to life did. I also don't feel like the personalities match? but that might just be my perception. I just can't wait to find how who it is - anyone could be right XD
|
|
|
Post by airbournebearcarcass on Apr 18, 2015 6:40:02 GMT
Assuming if the woman in amuro's memory was Elena, then I doubt Elan could be the unknown child, they don't look alike.
It is not about whether us readers like the idea of elena or toichi being alive after all, it is about the feasibility of them being alive. Since we are being kept in the dark about how exactly they died, it would be impossible to judge the feasibility of them being alive. If Aoyama sensei actually gives us the details of how they died, and then give a logical explanation how they faked their death and why they did that, I won't be complaining.
|
|
|
Post by sgamer82 on Feb 23, 2016 21:57:16 GMT
Bit of necromancy here but I wanted to add my own two cents in and hopefully add a little too the discussion.
When I last stopped following Conan, Sera and the Child had not been introduced yet. As I read about them, the idea the Child could be Elena definitely sparked. As I learn more and read the actual chapters I no longer think it's likely, but it is an interesting possibility.
I'm also curious, going by the last posts' dates, if anyone has reconsidered this theory one way or another given some of the more recent revelations like Haibara having a resemblance to the Child (end of the Department Store stabbing case) and, from there, that there may indeed be a blood connection between Haibara and the Child in particular/Akais in general. These also the fact the Child seems to be going by Mary and may be foreign.
Hm, random thought that occurred as I typed this: just as Haibara did it by mistake, the Child uses make up deliberately to make it look like she has the Akai-eyes. Unlikely, since she keeps herself shut in so appearances would be a minor issue, but maybe she's just that paranoid.
|
|
|
Post by boogum on Feb 23, 2016 22:37:49 GMT
I just get the feeling Aoyama is messing with us. I find it difficult to believe Mary can be related to Sera and Haibara; it has to be one or the other since Akai dated Akemi, and that would be weird (not unheard of, but still a bit weird for the year 2016). There are plenty of hints to suggest that Mary is related to Sera, etc, but then we've got the visual connection Shinichi makes when he sees Haibara with smudged mascara.
To be honest, I'm not really sure what I think at this point. There are a lot of connections being made at the moment, even in the latest two manga chapters, and I'm frankly too lazy/tired to work it out (never will be a detective, haha). I'm going to go ahead and say I think Mary probably won't end up being Elena, though.
|
|